Tempstar and Carrier are both well-recognized brands in the HVAC industry. Each has carved out a unique niche, offering a range of heating and cooling systems that cater to various markets and customer needs. Both are recognized for their quality, but they differ in terms of history, reputation, and product offerings.
When comparing Tempstar vs Carrier air conditioner units, there are several factors to consider. Here is a breakdown of the information from the search results:
Tempstar
- Tempstar air conditioners are more budget-friendly and affordable, making them a good option for those on a budget.
- They offer innovative features such as SmartSense Technology, which monitors fan and compressor operations, adjusts humidity levels, and maintains suitable temperatures for increased energy efficiency and performance.
- Tempstar excels in communication ability and ease of adjustments for controlling temperature and other factors.
- They have sound-level ratings that ensure quieter operation and enhanced comfort.
Carrier
- Carrier air conditioners are known for their performance.
- They may have a higher price point compared to Tempstar.
- Carrier air conditioners are considered more straightforward in terms of ease of use.
It’s important to note that Tempstar is an ICP product, owned by UT, which also owns Carrier. This may explain the similarities between the two brands. Ultimately, the choice between Tempstar and Carrier will depend on individual preferences, budget, and specific needs. It is recommended to consult with HVAC professionals and consider factors such as price, performance, features, and warranty before making a decision.
History and Reputation
Tempstar, a subsidiary of United Technologies Corporation (UTC), is known for its innovative design, reliability, and performance. This reputation has grown over the years as the company consistently delivers high-quality products at reasonable prices.
Carrier, on the other hand, is one of the oldest and most recognized names in the HVAC industry. Founded by Willis Carrier, the inventor of the modern air conditioning system, Carrier has consistently pushed boundaries and set the standard for the HVAC industry.
A Story From My Experience
A homeowner was planning on replacing their 25+ year old R22 AC system and they had narrowed down several quotes to a single company. They were now trying to decide between two of the options that they were quoted for: a Carrier system and a Tempstar system. Both systems were the same size (2 1/2TON – 14 SEER), but the Carrier system was around 10% more expensive.
The Options
The Carrier system (24ACC430A003 – Comfort Puron AC, FV4CNF003L00 – Blower) was priced $800 more than the Tempstar system (NXA430GKC – AC, FVM4X3600BL – Blower). The installer was Carrier certified either way, which is an important factor to consider as some technicians are sent to classes to learn the ins and outs of the systems.
Similarities and Differences
The homeowner’s research led them to understand that since Tempstar is made by Carrier, or the same company makes both, they are nearly identical and many parts are functionally the same, but with Carrier’s at a higher cost. The warranties were the same for both.
Despite the similarities, there might be some discrepancies if one starts looking around at gas valve and pressure switch model numbers, inducers, and other parts. Some off-brands might be less installation/maintenance/service friendly. For instance, the edges on Payne furnaces (another Carrier brand) are sharp, where Carriers are rounded over despite being from the same company with the same parts.
Making the Decision
The homeowner had no plans to move anytime soon, so they were trying to understand if there was any benefit to going with the more expensive option or if it was worthwhile to save a few hundred dollars. An important point to note is that if one option is $800 less, that money had to have been saved somewhere.
In such cases, buyers should be aware that bad parts, bad installs, or bad sales guys recommending systems either too big or too small for the application can cause issues, no matter what brand they choose. As such, the extra cost for a Carrier might be justified by the greater peace of mind it brings.
In terms of market share, Carrier holds a significant lead due to its long-standing history and extensive product range. Its HVAC systems are available globally, with a strong presence in both residential and commercial markets. Tempstar, though less dominant, has a strong North American presence and is growing its international footprint.
Air Conditioning Systems Comparison
| Criteria | Tempstar | Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Brand | Introduced in the early 1980s. Products include air conditioners, heat pumps, oil furnaces, ductless systems, gas furnaces, air purifiers, air scrubbers, fan coils, geothermal, evaporator coils, and thermostats. | Founded in 1915. Products include air conditioners, thermostats, smart thermostats, furnaces, ductless systems, traditional thermostats, air monitors, air purifiers, humidifiers, etc. |
| Efficiency Rating | Highest SEER rating: 19, Lowest SEER rating: 13 | Highest SEER rating: 26, Lowest SEER rating: 13 |
| Innovative Features | Features SmartSense Technology that monitors fan and compressor operations, Ion System Control for greater control of cooling system | Features Greenspeed Intelligence which manages speed ranges of the AC units, Infinity® System Control feature for remote access to the AC unit |
| Sound Level Rating | Highest sound rating: 76 decibels, Lowest sound rating: 56 decibels | Highest sound rating: 76 decibels, Lowest sound rating: 51 decibels |
| Range of Products | Ion™ System Air Conditioners and Performance Series | Infinity® system, Performance™ Series, and Comfort™ Series |
| Cost | Premium: $2,000 to $3,800 (unit alone), Installation: $5,000 to $7,500, Economical: $1,400 to $2,500 (unit alone), Installation: $3,500 to $4,500 | Premium: $2,500 to $4200 (unit alone), Installation: $5,400 to $8400, Mid-range: $2000 to $2,500 (unit alone), Installation: $5,200 to $5,500, Standard: $1,575 to $1,900 (unit alone), Installation: $4,800 to $5,100 |
| Warranty | Premium: 10-Year Parts Limited Warranty and No Hassle Replacement™ limited warranty, Economical: 5 years of warranty, Standard: 1 or 3 years of warranty | All product lines: 10-year parts limited warranty and a 10-year unit replacement limited warranty |
Efficiency and SEER Ratings
| SEER Ratings | Tempstar | Carrier |
|---|---|---|
| Average SEER | 16.2 | 16.4 |
| High SEER Models | Up to 19 | Up to 21 |
Both brands offer highly efficient models, but Carrier’s air conditioning systems slightly outperform Tempstar in terms of SEER ratings.
Types of Systems
Tempstar and Carrier both offer a wide variety of HVAC systems, including central air conditioning systems, heat pumps, and ductless mini-split systems.
Refrigerant and Environmental Impact
Both brands use R-410A, a refrigerant that is better for the environment than previous alternatives. However, they are also in the process of transitioning to newer, even more eco-friendly refrigerants like R-32.
Noise Levels and Comfort
Carrier’s systems tend to operate slightly quieter than Tempstar’s, but both brands have models that operate below the industry average noise level.
Product Range and Models
Residential AC Models
Both brands have a wide range of residential AC models. Tempstar’s models range from the economical Performance Series to the premium QuietComfort Series. Carrier’s models span from the Comfort Series to the high-end Infinity Series.
Commercial AC Models
Tempstar offers commercial AC units through its Commercial Series, while Carrier provides a variety of commercial solutions, from rooftop units to chillers and VRF systems.
Costs and Installation
Unit Pricing and Purchase Costs
Tempstar units tend to be more affordable, offering great value for their performance. On the other hand, Carrier units can be more expensive but are known for their advanced features and higher SEER ratings.
Installation Factors
The cost of installation can vary greatly depending on the specifics of your home or building, but both brands recommend installation by a certified professional to ensure optimal performance and longevity.
Running Costs and Energy Usage
Carrier’s higher SEER ratings can translate into lower energy usage and lower monthly costs over the life of the unit. Tempstar, while having slightly lower SEER ratings, still provides efficient units that can offer substantial energy savings.
Performance and Durability
Quality of Components
Both Tempstar and Carrier are known for their high-quality components. However, Carrier is often recognized for its superior build quality, while Tempstar is noted for its balance of quality and affordability.
Energy Efficiency and EER
Both brands offer models with high EER ratings, indicating strong energy efficiency. However, on average, Carrier models tend to have slightly higher EER ratings.
Warranty and Repair Services
Carrier typically offers a 10-year parts limited warranty on registered products, which can provide customers with peace of mind. Tempstar also offers a 10-year parts limited warranty on most of its models. In terms of repair services, both brands have a broad network of certified technicians across North America.
A Closer Look at Specific Models
To further delve into the comparison between Tempstar and Carrier, it’s beneficial to consider specific models within their product lines.
Tempstar QuietComfort Deluxe 19
This high-end model from Tempstar has a SEER rating of 19, making it one of the most efficient models in Tempstar’s lineup. It’s designed to operate quietly, with a sound rating as low as 56 decibels.
| Feature | QuietComfort Deluxe 19 |
|---|---|
| SEER Rating | 19 |
| Noise Level | As low as 56 dB |
| Warranty | 10 years |
Carrier Infinity 21
The Carrier Infinity 21 is a top-tier model from Carrier with a SEER rating of 21. Like the Tempstar model, it’s designed for quiet operation, with a sound rating as low as 65 decibels.
| Feature | Infinity 21 |
|---|---|
| SEER Rating | 21 |
| Noise Level | As low as 65 dB |
| Warranty | 10 years |
While both models are high-end offerings with impressive performance and efficiency, the Carrier Infinity 21 slightly edges out the Tempstar QuietComfort Deluxe 19 in terms of SEER rating, but it’s also likely to come with a higher price tag.
Conclusion
When choosing between Tempstar and Carrier, the decision ultimately comes down to your specific needs and budget.
If you are looking for a balance of affordability and performance, Tempstar is a strong choice. Their units offer good efficiency and reliability at a more affordable price point.
If, on the other hand, you are willing to invest in a higher-priced unit for top-of-the-line features and efficiency, Carrier’s offerings might be more appealing.
Regardless of the brand you choose, it’s important to consider factors like energy efficiency, noise level, warranty, and the overall quality of components when making your decision. Both Tempstar and Carrier offer a range of models to suit different needs, so you can find the right HVAC solution for your home or business.
Mason Harper is a dedicated and passionate home comfort and air quality expert. With a degree in Mechanical Engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and over a decade of experience in the HVAC industry, Mason has an in-depth understanding of the technical elements of air quality and home comfort products.
Leave a Reply