When it comes to home heating and cooling systems, few decisions are as important as choosing the right HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning) equipment. Investing in a quality system can pay dividends through improved comfort, energy efficiency, and reliability for years to come. Two of the most recognized names in the HVAC industry are Amana and Goodman, both owned by the parent company Daikin. But which brand offers the better HVAC systems overall?
In this comprehensive comparison, we’ll examine the key differences between Amana and Goodman across critical categories like efficiency, warranties, price, and product lines. By the end, you’ll have the information you need to determine which brand is right for your home.
HVAC Efficiency
A HVAC system’s efficiency determines how much energy it uses to heat or cool your home. The more efficient the system, the lower your utility bills will be. When it comes to efficiency, Amana systems tend to outperform Goodman.
SEER Ratings
The Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) measures how efficiently an air conditioner cools. The higher the SEER, the more energy efficient the AC unit. Most Amana air conditioners meet or exceed 14 SEER, while Goodman ACs range from 13 to 16 SEER. Higher-end Amana models with variable speed compressors can reach SEERs of 20+ for even greater efficiency.
AFUE Ratings
The Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency (AFUE) rate indicates the efficiency of a furnace or boiler. Again, Amana furnaces tend to have higher AFUE ratings than comparable Goodman models. Many Amana furnaces achieve 97% AFUE or greater, while Goodman furnaces range from 80% to 97% AFUE.
The higher SEER and AFUE ratings of Amana’s HVAC equipment translate directly to lower energy bills compared to equivalent Goodman units. Over years of operation, the savings can really add up.
Warranties
The warranty coverage for HVAC components indicates how confident the manufacturer is in their product’s reliability. Once again, Amana comes out ahead of Goodman based on the length and scope of their warranties.
Parts Warranties
Amana provides a Limited Lifetime Unit Replacement warranty that covers the entire HVAC unit for as long as you own your home. Goodman’s best warranty is 10 years on parts. For such a major appliance, Amana’s lifetime coverage provides valuable peace of mind.
Compressor Warranties
The compressor is the heart of an AC unit, and one of the most likely components to fail. Amana again wins out by including the compressor in its lifetime parts warranty. Goodman only warrants the compressor for 10 years.
Heat Exchanger Warranties
For furnaces, the heat exchanger is a critical component that can be very expensive to replace. Amana offers a Limited Lifetime warranty on heat exchangers, whereas Goodman’s best heat exchanger warranty is 20 years.
Overall, Amana’s superior warranty terms demonstrate greater faith that their HVAC products will provide lasting performance. This suggests Amana systems should prove more reliable and have lower repair and replacement costs over their operational lifetime.
HVAC Product Lines
Both Amana and Goodman offer a full suite of residential HVAC systems. Their product offerings are actually quite similar, as one might expect given they share a parent company. However, there are some notable differences.
Air Conditioners
Amana and Goodman have comparable air conditioner lines ranging from basic budget models up to premium variable speed and multi-stage units. Amana claims to have the quietest air conditioners in the industry, with sound isolation enhancements to reduce noise. They also promote their heavy-duty outdoor coils and louvered panels for increased durability.
Heat Pumps
Heat pumps provide both heating and cooling from one dual-purpose unit. Again, Amana and Goodman provide similar tiers of heat pumps. However, Amana highlights their unique self-monitoring control board that proactively alerts homeowners to any potential issues. This allows for preventative maintenance before major failures occur.
Gas Furnaces
Both brands offer high-efficiency single and multi-stage furnaces. Amana furnaces feature specially designed heat exchangers to maximize heat transfer. They also utilize variable speed blowers for added comfort. Goodman furnaces provide reliable heating at a lower upfront cost.
Oil Furnaces
While not as common as gas furnaces, oil-fired heating systems are a necessity in some regions. Amana produces oil furnaces engineered for maximum efficiency and longevity. Goodman’s oil furnace offerings are more limited.
In terms of product selection, Amana and Goodman are comparable overall. Amana emphasizes advanced features for performance and sound reduction, while Goodman focuses more on budget-friendly basics.
HVAC Installation and Maintenance
Installing and maintaining an HVAC system properly is key to ensuring its longevity. Both Amana and Goodman rely on professional dealers and contractors to handle installation and service. However, Amana dealers must meet more stringent training requirements around proper sizing, installation, and maintenance. This helps ensure optimal performance from Amana HVAC systems.
Goodman dealers receive basic training on installation and service. But qualifications vary more widely, so be sure to verify expertise when hiring a Goodman contractor. Getting a poorly installed or maintained Goodman unit could lead to unexpected headaches down the road.
Cost Comparison
Upfront price is a major factor for most HVAC buyers. As you might expect given the differences we’ve covered, Amana systems typically cost more than comparable Goodman models. You’re paying a premium for higher efficiency, better warranties, lower sound levels, and advanced features.
However, experts point out that over the total lifespan, Amana units can actually save money compared to Goodman. The improved efficiency cuts energy usage, helping offset the higher initial cost. And if the Goodman unit needs repairs or replacement parts during the warranty period, you’ll be responsible for those added costs.
So while Goodman may be tempting for budget-conscious homeowners, you risk paying more in the long run. On the other hand, paying a little extra for Amana upfront can pay dividends through lower operating costs and fewer repairs down the road.
Availability
Being able to actually purchase and install your chosen HVAC system is also crucial. While both brands are sold through heating and cooling contractors across North America, Amana’s network of authorized dealers is smaller. If you have your heart set on Amana equipment, you may have fewer local options to purchase and install it.
Goodman’s large dealer network gives buyers many more choices for HVAC contractors in most areas. Just be sure to vet each company thoroughly, as skill levels can vary. But in general Goodman units should be easier to find and purchase in your location.
Choosing Between Amana and Goodman
When weighing all the factors – efficiency, warranties, cost, availability, and more – Amana furnaces and air conditioners tend to come out ahead of Goodman. You’ll typically pay more upfront for an Amana HVAC system, but the long-term benefits often justify the added initial investment. This is especially true if energy efficiency is one of your top priorities.
However, Goodman remains a solid choice for shoppers simply seeking reliable heating and cooling on a tight budget. While their units lag Amana in some areas like warranties and efficiency, they can still deliver satisfactory performance at an appealing price point.
Carefully matching potential HVAC systems to your specific needs is the best way to determine whether Amana or Goodman is preferable for your situation. Consult with qualified local HVAC professionals, get quotes for different setups, and make an informed decision based on total long-term costs and value. With some due diligence, you can invest in a new Amana or Goodman HVAC system that will keep your home comfortable for years.
My Take on Amana vs Goodman HVAC
As an HVAC enthusiast, I’m always eager to dig into the details on major brands like Amana and Goodman. Both make quality heating and cooling systems, but have some different strengths. Here’s my take on how they compare after researching the key factors.
Efficiency
Gotta love high-efficiency HVAC! Nothing beats saving money on energy bills while staying comfortable.
| Brand | Higher Efficiency |
|---|---|
| Amana | Amana units tend to have higher AFUE and SEER ratings, meaning better efficiency. |
| Goodman | Goodman isn’t too far behind, but can’t match Amana’s numbers in my experience. |
Advantage: Amana
Noise Levels
A loud, droning AC unit can drive you crazy in the summer. I prefer systems that run quiet.
| Brand | Noise Level |
|---|---|
| Amana | They isolate the compressor to reduce noise. Their ACs are among the quietest. |
| Goodman | Goodman units tend to be louder based on decibel testing. Not horrible, but noticeably nosier. |
Advantage: Amana
Warranties
You want an HVAC system built to last. The warranty says a lot about durability.
| Brand | Warranty |
|---|---|
| Amana | Offers a lifetime warranty on parts and the heat exchanger. Very reassuring! |
| Goodman | Just 10 years on parts and 20 on the heat exchanger. Not awful but I prefer Amana’s coverage. |
Advantage: Amana
My Conclusion
For my money, Amana comes out ahead as the better HVAC brand overall. Their higher efficiency ratings, quieter operation, and lifetime warranty coverage give them the edge in my book.
However, Goodman remains a decent budget-friendly option. Their units just can’t match Amana in key areas like noise and warranties. But if you want basic heating and cooling on a tight budget, Goodman gets the job done.
Either brand will provide many years of reliable service when properly installed and maintained. Do your research to pick the right system for your needs and home!
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is Amana really that much more efficient than Goodman?
A: Based on AFUE and SEER ratings, Amana units do tend to be more efficient, sometimes by a significant margin. Those ratings translate into real energy savings.
Q: How big a difference is there in noise levels?
A: In decibel testing, Amana ACs rated about 2-4 decibels quieter than comparable Goodman models. A few decibels is a noticeable difference.
Q: Do Goodman units break down more often?
A: There’s no evidence Goodman has widespread reliability issues. But Amana’s superior warranty indicates they expect fewer problems down the line. Proper maintenance is key for either brand.
Q: Why are Amana HVAC systems more expensive?
A: You pay a premium for the increased efficiency, soundproofing, and longer warranties. Long-term cost savings may offset the higher initial investment.
Q: Is a Goodman heat pump or AC good for a basic system?
A: If budget is your main concern, a Goodman heat pump or AC provides decent comfort at a lower price point. Just don’t expect premium features and efficiency.
Mason Harper is a dedicated and passionate home comfort and air quality expert. With a degree in Mechanical Engineering from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and over a decade of experience in the HVAC industry, Mason has an in-depth understanding of the technical elements of air quality and home comfort products.
Leave a Reply